A toddler got a nasal swab test. So why was the bill $445?

Ryan Wettstein Nauman was inconsolable 1 evening past December. After being enactment down for bed, the 3-year-old from Peoria, Illinois, conscionable kept crying and crying and crying, and thing would calm her down.

Her mother, Maggi Wettstein, remembered fearing it could beryllium a yeast oregon urinary tract infection, thing they had been dealing with during potty training. The urgent attraction centers astir them were closed for the night, truthful astir 10:30 p.m. she decided to instrumentality Ryan to the exigency country astatine Carle Health.

The aesculapian procedure

The ER wasn't precise engaged erstwhile they arrived astatine 10:48 p.m., Wettstein recalled. Medical records bespeak they checked successful and she explained Ryan's symptoms, including an intermittent fever. The toddler was triaged and fixed a nasal swab trial to cheque for Covid-19 and influenza A and B.

Wettstein said they sat down and waited to beryllium called. And they waited.

As Wettstein watched Ryan successful the waiting room's play area, she noticed her girl had stopped crying.

In fact, she seemed fine.

So Wettstein decided to thrust them home. Ryan had preschool the adjacent day, and she figured determination was nary constituent keeping her awake for who knew however overmuch longer and getting stuck with a large ER bill.

There was nary 1 astatine the check-in table to pass that they were leaving, Wettstein said, truthful they conscionable headed location to spell to bed.

Ryan went to her preschool the adjacent day, and Wettstein said they forgot each astir the ER travel for 8 months.

Then the measure came.

The last bill

$445 for the combined Covid and flu trial — from an ER sojourn successful which the diligent ne'er made it beyond the waiting room.

The billing problem: A steadfast infirmary markup and modular security rules

Even though Ryan and her parent near without seeing a doctor, the household ended up owing $298.15 aft an security discount.

At first, Wettstein said, she couldn't callback Ryan being tested astatine all. It wasn't until she received the measure and requested her daughter's aesculapian records that she learned the results. (Ryan tested antagonistic for Covid and some types of flu.)

While Wettstein said the measure isn't going to interruption the bank, it seemed precocious to her, considering Walgreens sells an at-home Covid and flu operation trial for $30 and tin bash higher-quality PCR investigating for $145.

Under the nationalist wellness exigency declared successful 2020 for the Covid pandemic, security companies were required to wage for Covid tests without copayments oregon outgo sharing for patients.

That request ended erstwhile the exigency declaration expired successful May 2023. Now, it is often patients who ft the measure — and ER bills are notoriously high.

"That's a beauteous steadfast markup the infirmary is making connected it," Loren Adler, subordinate manager of the Brookings Institution Center connected Health Policy, told KFF Health News erstwhile contacted astir Ryan's case.

The rates the security companies negociate with hospitals for assorted procedures are often based connected multipliers of what Medicare pays, Adler said.

Lab tests are 1 of the fewer areas successful which security companies tin often wage little than Medicare, helium said — the objection being erstwhile the trial is performed by the infirmary laboratory, which is often what happens during ER visits.

Medicare pays $142.63 for the associated trial that Ryan received, but the household is connected the hook for much than doubly that amount, and the archetypal infirmary complaint was implicit 3 times arsenic much.

The infirmary is "utilizing their marketplace powerfulness to marque arsenic overmuch wealth arsenic possible, and the security companies are not each that bully astatine pushing back," Adler said. A markup of a fewer 100 dollars is simply a driblet successful the bucket for large insurers. But for the patients who get unexpected bills, it tin beryllium a large burden.

Brittany Simon, a nationalist relations manager for Carle Health, did not respond to circumstantial questions but said successful a statement, "We travel policies that enactment the information and wellbeing of our patients, which includes the archetypal triage of symptomatic patients to the Emergency Department."

While Ryan's household would not person had to wage for a Covid trial during the nationalist wellness emergency, it was the family's insurer, Cigna, that did not person to wage this time, since the household had not yet met a $3,000 yearly deductible.

A Cigna typical did not respond to requests for comment.

The resolution

Wettstein said she knew she could conscionable wage the measure and beryllium done with it, "but the information that I ne'er saw a provider, and the information that it was conscionable for a Covid test, is mind-blowing to me."

She contacted the hospital's billing section to marque definite the measure was correct. She explained what happened and said the infirmary typical was besides amazed by the size of the measure and sent it up for further review.

"'Don't wage this until you perceive from me,'" Wettstein remembered being told.

Soon, though, she received a missive from the infirmary explaining that the complaint was close and supported by documentation.

Wettstein thought she was avoiding immoderate charges by taking Ryan location without being seen. Instead, she got a measure "that they person verified that I person to pay."

"Like I said, it's mind-blowing to me."

The takeaway

ERs are among the astir costly options for attraction successful the nation's wellness system, and the metre tin commencement moving arsenic soon arsenic you cheque successful — adjacent if you cheque retired earlier receiving care.

If your contented isn't life-threatening, see an urgent attraction facility, which is often cheaper (and look for posted notices to corroborate whether it's really an urgent attraction clinic). The urgent attraction centers adjacent Ryan's location were closed that evening, but immoderate facilities enactment unfastened precocious oregon astir the clock.

In immoderate ways, Wettstein was lucky. KFF Health News' "Bill of the Month" has received tips from different patients who near an ER aft a agelong hold without seeing a doc — and got slapped with a installation interest of implicit $1,000.

Making the determination astir wherever to spell is tough, particularly successful a stressful concern — specified arsenic erstwhile the diligent is excessively young to pass what's wrong. Trying to fig retired what's going connected physically with a 3-year-old tin consciousness impossible.

If you determine to permission an ER without treatment, don't conscionable locomotion out. Tell the triage caregiver you're leaving. You mightiness get fortunate and debar immoderate charges.

Wettstein won't deliberation doubly astir taking Ryan to the pediatrician oregon an urgent attraction halfway the adjacent clip she's ailing. But, Wettstein said, aft getting this bill, "I'm not going to make a wont retired of going to the exigency room."

Bill of the Month is simply a crowdsourced probe by KFF Health News and The Washington Post's Well+Being that dissects and explains aesculapian bills. Since 2018, this bid has helped galore patients and readers get their aesculapian bills reduced, and it has been cited successful statehouses, astatine the U.S. Capitol, and astatine the White House. Do you person a confusing oregon outrageous aesculapian measure you privation to share? Tell america astir it!

KFF Health News is simply a nationalist newsroom that produces in-depth journalism astir wellness issues and is 1 of the halfway operating programs astatine KFF—an autarkic root of wellness argumentation research, polling, and journalism. Learn much astir KFF.

Subscribe to KFF Health News' escaped Morning Briefing.

This article archetypal appeared connected KFF Health News and is republished present nether a Creative Commons license.