How Harris and Trump's stances on Medicare compare

1 month ago 39

The aboriginal of Medicare, America's sweeping wellness security programme for older adults, continues to travel up connected the run way from some Vice President Kamala Harris and erstwhile President Donald Trump during this last agelong starring up to the 2024 statesmanlike election.

This year's voting comes astatine a clip erstwhile the 67.5 cardinal Americans enrolled successful Medicare plans are starting to spot significant changes, mostly resulting from the Inflation Reduction Act that Vice President Kamala Harris formed a tie-breaking ballot for successful 2022. 

Harris has touted the law's much generous medicine spending benefits for seniors, which Biden medication officials accidental person not resulted successful feared premium spikes oregon cutbacks for astir cause plans.

Some of that "stabilization" is the effect of billions poured into premium-lowering efforts, which Republicans person voiced frustration implicit arsenic an "election twelvemonth stunt." Premiums for Medicare Part B are besides continuing to grow, up to an estimated $185 monthly in 2025.

The enactment has besides offered immoderate respite for lawmakers grappling with the program's long-running insolvency crisis, arsenic spending is inactive outpacing the taxes that money it. Medicare's spot money present has until 2036 earlier it is acceptable to tally out, acknowledgment successful ample portion to savings from the instrumentality and an economical rebound pursuing the COVID-19 pandemic.

Harris wants to grow Medicare benefits

Harris has made her proposal to grow Medicare's coverage for location wellness attraction aides a communal portion of her stump code successful caller weeks. The program besides calls for adding sum for proceeding and imaginativeness benefits to Medicare.

Expanding the caller benefits could beryllium paid for by a abstracted Harris connection to grow the Medicare Drug Price Negotiation Program, which was created by the Inflation Reduction Act.

The terms caps programme nether its existent plan volition beryllium excessively tiny to screen the expanded benefits Harris wants. But the run has pointed to estimates suggesting that billions much could beryllium recouped by a much assertive attack to its terms caps and different cause outgo reforms, if Congress signs off.

Former President Donald Trump's run responded to the Harris announcement by pointing to their ain promises successful the Republican level this year, including "shifting resources backmost to at-home care." 

They besides cited changes Medicare made during the COVID-19 pandemic nether Trump, similar expanding entree to telehealth providers.

Trump wants to artifact Medicare property increases

A predominant applause enactment astatine Trump's rallies is his pledge to artifact immoderate increases to the eligibility property for Medicare coverage, which is presently acceptable astatine 65 years old, and to destruct income taxes on Social Security benefits.

"I volition combat for and support Social Security and Medicare. There volition beryllium nary cuts, and we won't beryllium raising the age, similar they're going to extremity up doing," Trump told supporters astatine a Pennsylvania rally connected Oct. 9. 

Those promises could adhd to the steep challenges facing Congress, arsenic it navigates the thorny solutions to Medicare insolvency. Though the deadline for Medicare moving retired of wealth has been pushed back, officials person warned Congress that delaying enactment present to enactment up the money volition unit adjacent much achy changes down the road.

While Trump has painted his pledge arsenic a broadside against his Democratic rival, the status property contented was really a constituent of part wrong his ain enactment during the GOP primary. House Democrats person besides railed against immoderate of their GOP colleagues implicit a program that suggested "modest adjustments to the status age" down the road.

Harris accuses Trump of backing cuts to Medicare

Democrats person accused Trump of backing cuts to Medicare for years, contempt his repeated vows not to chopped the program's funding.

The Harris run has revived attacks from Trump's archetypal term, which claimed his projected budgets were cutting "Medicare enactment for hospitals and different providers nether the guise of eliminating wasteful spending."

"Now Donald Trump has a antithetic approach. He tried to chopped Medicare and Social Security each twelvemonth helium was president," Harris said connected Oct. 29, successful remarks adjacent the White House that the run billed arsenic her closing argument.

At the time, Trump White House officials defended the savings arsenic bully authorities reforms and said Medicare's backing would inactive turn nether the budget. The changes mostly echoed recommendations by a nonpartisan advisory commission to amended the program, and extracurricular fund watchdogs agreed it would not straight interaction beneficiaries.

Harris has besides claimed that her Republican hostile would chopped Medicare and overturn provisions the Inflation Reduction Act added, similar the Medicare Drug Price Negotiation Program. As evidence, she cites proposals successful the Heritage Foundation's "Project 2025" platform, written by Trump allies, contempt his ain disavowal of the document.

Trump accuses Harris of "bankrupting" the program

On the trail, Trump astir often brings up Medicare erstwhile accusing Harris of "bankrupting" the program. He frames the onslaught the aforesaid mode helium did against President Biden earlier this year, earlier Mr. Biden dropped out, claiming a surge of migrants was "destroying" Medicare.

"They're allowing millions of these radical to spell into Social Security, Medicare. They're going to destruct it," Trump said connected Oct. 29, successful remarks from his Mar-a-Lago edifice successful Florida.

Under existent law, undocumented immigrants are not eligible for Medicare. Only immoderate "lawfully contiguous immigrants" tin get premium-free Medicare, typically lone aft those seniors person paid payroll taxes successful capable years.

A much nuanced mentation of Trump's attack, published by his campaign, points to Harris' enactment for an "earned pathway to citizenship" for immigrants. The Trump run claims this could "make millions of low-wage migrants into US citizens" and endanger the endurance of the program.

This echoes a akin assertion that has travel up successful Washington for years. A failed migration betterment effort in 2013 that sought to carve retired a "pathway to citizenship" was projected to effect successful higher Medicare spending to screen the further people, though it was besides projected to bring successful much taxation gross that could outweigh the accrued expenses.

The Harris run has promised to lick Medicare's backing shortfall "by making corporations and the wealthiest Americans wage their just stock successful taxes."

Alexander Tin

Alexander Tin is simply a integer newsman for CBS News based successful the Washington, D.C. bureau. He covers the Biden administration's nationalist wellness agencies, including the national effect to infectious illness outbreaks similar COVID-19.

Read Entire Article