2 weeks ago
68
We present person wide impervious of the adage that a prevarication gets halfway astir the satellite earlier the information tin enactment its boots on.
It comes successful the signifier of an Associated Press study that carried this headline: “Hamas authoritative says radical would laic down its arms if an autarkic Palestinian authorities is established.”
What a scoop!
It was truthful sensational that quality outlets crossed America and the satellite ran with it, including CNN, ABC News and adjacent the Times of Israel.
And wherefore not, it was a breakthrough connection that could bring bid astatine last, right?
Wrong.
It was a nationalist relations ploy disguised arsenic an olive branch.
The mode different organizations swallowed it hook, enactment and sinker illustrates however Hamas skillfully plays occidental quality organizations and gullible journalists.
The incidental besides demonstrates however acold the AP has fallen from its days arsenic a boring but trustworthy quality organization.
In a contention to rack up clicks, it has featured the nonfiction connected apical of its online “world” conception since Wednesday contempt the information that it’s a dormant letter.
The story, based connected an interrogation with a Hamas person successful Turkey by an AP freelancer, was misleading and woefully incomplete.
And it came loaded with the AP’s accustomed bias against Israel.
It called Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government “hard line” for rejecting a Palestinian state.
Meanwhile, Hamas was called a “militant group” and its terrorists described arsenic members of its “military wing.”
To its credit, the Times of Israel saw done the ploy.
In summation to adding different details that undercut the mode the AP portrayed the offering arsenic a concession, it reported that the aforesaid Hamas authoritative who spoke to the AP, Khalil al-Hayy, delivered a antithetic connection to a London-based Arabic paper.
There helium said that, careless of immoderate woody with Israel, the Palestinians would clasp their “historic close to each Palestinian lands.”
In different words, Hamas claims each the onshore “from the stream to the sea” and remains deadly superior astir wiping Israel disconnected the map.
Although the AP deserves the blasted for the distortions, including however it underplayed the conditions the Hamas person attached, immoderate writer who work the full portion should person seen done it.
Even Israel-bashing CNN should person figured this 1 out.
Certainly the American and Israeli governments did, which is wherefore neither took the interrogation earnestly contempt their eagerness to mates a cease-fire with the merchandise of the hostages Hamas is holding.
In truth, the conditions attached to the committedness of bid were truthful onerous that they amounted to poison pills and uncover — arsenic if determination was immoderate uncertainty — Hamas is not superior astir ending the warfare it started.
Border madness
One information was a instrumentality to the pre-1967 borders of Israel, which would mean it would request to relinquish each of East Jerusalem and the West Bank, which, joined with Gaza, would marque up the caller Palestinian state.
The Golan Heights, which Israel took from Syria successful the Yom Kippur War of 1973, besides would person to beryllium returned.
The 2nd nonstarter was the request that each “refugees” who near pre-’67 Israel would person the close of return.
Including each those who near voluntarily oregon were forced out, positive their descendants, the full would beryllium astir 6 cardinal Arabs, meaning the extremity of Israel arsenic a Jewish bulk state.
Notably, the AP communicative did not notation that fig oregon its interaction connected Israel.
A 3rd information was that Hamas terrorists would go portion of a caller Palestinian National Army.
That would mean amnesty for those who took portion successful the savage brutality of Oct. 7, 2023, and supply them with different accidental to termination much Jews.
Seen done the conditions, the interrogation revealed that Hamas volition lone soundlessness its guns temporarily and past lone if Israel signs its ain decease warrant.
Although determination is nary transportation betwixt the AP interrogation and the dispersed of pro-Hamas demonstrations connected American assemblage campuses, some developments service to underscore the ignorance of galore Americans astir the Mideast.
And that includes acold excessively galore members of the media.
The duplicate developments besides bespeak a “blame the Jews” mindset that is portion and parcel of the shocking outbreak of antisemitism successful the United States and astir the world.
It is particularly caput boggling to recognize this lurch backwards to the past hatred came aft Israel suffered a violent onslaught that claimed much Jewish lives than immoderate time since the extremity of the Holocaust.
As for the Hamas treble speak, Israelis are agelong accustomed to the wont of Palestinian leaders saying 1 happening to English-speaking audiences and thing wholly antithetic to Arabic audiences.
Hamas has go adept astatine the scam, and knowing that is apt what led the Times of Israel to observe the Arabic-language insubstantial wherever al-Hayya contradicted what helium said to the AP.
It was determination helium stressed that Hamas is inactive committed to destroying Israel and would stay truthful adjacent if a cease-fire took place.
Ridiculously ignorant
Yet opposition that world with the assemblage students who, chorus-like, reflexively repetition the refrain that Israel is the 1 who is blameworthy of committing “genocide” successful Gaza.
It’s a ridiculously ignorant charge, and the numbers beryllium it.
The beachfront portion has 1 of the world’s highest rates of colonisation growth, according to the US Census, and had a prewar colonisation of 2.3 million.
And portion the AP cited “local wellness authorities” to accidental Israel’s penetration has “killed much than 34,000 Palestinians, astir of them women and children,” it doesn’t study that Israel says it has killed much than 13,000 terrorists.
Indeed, that’s not a fig you volition perceive successful astir American media and surely not successful assemblage protester tents.
It’s arsenic if not a azygous violent has been killed and each those who died successful Gaza were innocent.
Even aft Gaza wellness officials, who enactment for Hamas, lied that 500 civilians died successful an Israeli onslaught connected a infirmary erstwhile nary onslaught occurred, the media inactive cites immoderate numbers they release.
Ditto for their claims of wide famine, which is ever conscionable days away, and has been for months.
The repetition by the media and protesters of immoderate scare fig Hamas puts retired helps explicate wherefore its leaders expressed gratitude for the enactment they get astatine the demonstrations.
They admit having their lies repeated and magnified by American dupes.
To beryllium clear, the nonaccomplishment of a azygous guiltless civilian is tragic, but Israel goes to bonzer lengths to minimize civilian casualties.
In fact, taking some the Hamas claims of full deaths and the Israeli claims of terrorists killed, it would mean astir 40 percent were combatants.
That’s a proportionality acold amended than adjacent the American subject achieved successful wars that progressive municipality combat, arsenic this 1 surely does.
Oops, sorry.
I apologize for letting facts get successful the mode of the large lie
English (US) ·